Loading…
Demo: these projects and quotes are fictional. Nothing you enter here is saved or sent anywhere.
Loading…
3 quotes, 18 items checked. The quotes differ on 10 items, and 11 items need a question before the quotes are comparable.
Totals are shown as each contractor stated them. They don't cover the same work yet, so a lower total isn't necessarily a better deal.
Quote A: Alder Roofing Co.
$9,850.00
Total as stated in the quote
Quote B: Harborline Exteriors
$11,200.00
Total as stated in the quote
Quote C: Bluestone Roofing
$10,480.00
Total as stated in the quote
Open "Source" to see the exact words from each quote. Fixing a wrongly read item comes in a later version.
Not mentioned means the quote is silent about it. That isn't the same as explicitly excluded, so it's worth asking.
Says damaged decking will be replaced as needed, with no price per sheet.
Ask: No price or limit for replacement decking.
Replace damaged decking as needed(page 1)
First 3 sheets of decking included, then $85 per sheet.
Up to 3 sheets of plywood included; additional sheets $85 each(page 1)
Replacement decking at $90 per sheet.
Rotted decking replaced at $90 per sheet(page 1)
Ice and water barrier at eaves and valleys.
Ice and water barrier at all eaves and valleys(page 1)
Ice and water barrier along eaves.
Ice and water barrier, 6 ft at eaves(page 1)
Mentions flashing without saying which flashing or whether it is replaced.
Ask: Doesn't say which flashing is replaced or reused.
Flashing as needed(page 1)
Replaces step flashing and pipe boots.
Replace all step flashing and pipe boots(page 1)
New pipe boots and chimney flashing.
New pipe boots and chimney flashing(page 1)
New aluminum drip edge.
New aluminum drip edge, eaves and rakes(page 1)
New drip edge.
New drip edge installed(page 1)
Continuous ridge vent.
Install continuous ridge vent(page 2)
Ridge vent installed.
Ridge vent installation(page 1)
Architectural shingles, no manufacturer or product line named.
Ask: No manufacturer or product line named.
Architectural shingles, color to be selected(page 1)
Keystone Pro 30 architectural shingles.
Keystone Pro 30 architectural shingles(page 1)
Keystone Pro 30 architectural shingles.
Keystone Pro 30 shingles, architectural style(page 1)
Gutters are not included.
Gutters not included(page 2)
Permit fee included.
Permit fee included in price(page 2)
Pulls the permit and schedules inspection.
We obtain the building permit and schedule final inspection(page 2)
Mentions a permit only "if required", without saying who pays.
Ask: Doesn't say who obtains or pays for the permit.
Permit if required(page 2)
10-year workmanship warranty.
10-year workmanship warranty(page 2)
Page 1 says a 5-year labor warranty; page 3 says a 2-year workmanship warranty.
Ask: The two warranty lengths don't match.
5-year labor warranty(page 1)
Workmanship warranted for two (2) years(page 3)
5-year workmanship warranty.
5-year workmanship warranty(page 2)
Manufacturer's limited lifetime warranty on shingles.
Manufacturer's limited lifetime shingle warranty(page 2)
Manufacturer warranty on shingles.
Shingles carry the manufacturer's warranty(page 2)
License number and insurance listed.
License #RC-20417, general liability insured(page 3)
License number listed.
Licensed contractor #RC-31188(page 2)
Removes existing shingles down to the deck.
Tear off existing shingles to deck(page 1)
Full tear-off to the deck.
Complete tear-off of existing roofing to the deck(page 1)
Removes all existing layers.
Remove all existing roofing layers(page 1)
Dumpster and haul-away included.
Dumpster and haul-away of all debris(page 1)
Disposal fees included.
All disposal fees included(page 1)
Haul-away included.
Haul away and dispose of all debris(page 1)
Synthetic underlayment, no brand named.
Synthetic underlayment over entire roof(page 1)
TrueDeck synthetic underlayment.
TrueDeck synthetic underlayment(page 1)
Synthetic underlayment.
Synthetic underlayment(page 1)
The home has no skylights.
The home has no skylights.
The home has no skylights.
Daily cleanup and magnetic nail sweep.
Daily cleanup and magnetic nail sweep(page 2)
Full cleanup with magnet sweep.
Full site cleanup with magnet sweep(page 2)
Cleanup and nail sweep.
Cleanup and nail sweep at completion(page 2)
Two to three days.
Estimated 2-3 working days(page 2)
About 3 days, start within 2 weeks of signing.
Approximately 3 days; start within 2 weeks of signing(page 2)
Two days.
2 day installation(page 2)
Half at signing, half on completion.
50% at signing, balance on completion(page 2)
30% deposit, 40% at material delivery, 30% at completion.
30% deposit, 40% on material delivery, 30% on completion(page 3)
One-third deposit, balance on completion.
1/3 deposit, balance due on completion(page 2)
WhatsInMyQuote drafts a neutral letter asking every contractor to price the same work and answer the open questions.
Draft the request